- Free Shipping on orders $125+ in contiguous U.S.
- 30 Day Happiness Guarantee
- Most Orders Process in 1-2 Days
Order by 12pm 12/14 for UPS Ground Delivery
Order by 12pm 12/17 for USPS Priority
Order by 12pm 12/21 for Local Delivery
The "key" to finding a toy that's popular with baby? Go with the classics! The First Years First Keys are five brightly-colored keys that swing freely on their ring to make a lively click-clack sound. Each key is a different shape, with rounded edges that babies love to chew on. Plus, the keys are numbered, so you can use them to teach counting and number recognition. Unlock some fun with The First Years First Keys Toy!
Frequently Asked Questions
When Will My Order Ship?
Most orders are processed to ship in 1 - 2 days.
Can I Get Free Shipping?
Yes! All orders over $125 ship for free in the contiguous U.S.
Whats Your 30 Day Return Policy?
We want you to be happy with the purchases you make. If you're not satisfied, you may return or exchange within 30 days of the shipment's receipt. For more info checkout our Refund Policy Page.
How can I reach customer support?
Give us a call:
Monday - Saturday: 10am - 6pm EST
Sunday: 10am - 4pm EST
We're Experts in Play
Every toy at Timeless Toys is hand picked by our team of Certified Play Experts. From the trending to the timeless, from the tots to teens we have something for everyone.